Scripture · Acts 2:37-41
Matthew 17:27
The Tribute Money
“But so that we may not offend them, go to the sea, cast a hook, and take the first fish you catch. When you open its mouth, you will find a four-drachma coin. Take it and give it to them for My tax and yours.”
Jesus directs Peter toward the lake at the center, while Peter retrieves a coin at the far left and pays the collector at the right.
About the artwork
Masaccio tells three moments across a single landscape. Peter’s repeated appearance lets the viewer follow instruction, discovery and payment without separate frames. The central group supplies the starting point, so the sequence requires looking outward and then across the fresco rather than simply reading from left to right.
The work belongs to the Brancacci Chapel in Florence and dates to the 1420s. Solid bodies and a continuous mountain setting hold the separate actions together. The tax collector’s presence makes the practical problem visible, while the small action at the water gives the answer a place within Peter’s familiar world.
What does Matthew 17:27 mean?
Matthew 17:24–27 concerns the temple contribution, distinct from the later question about taxes paid to Caesar. When the collectors ask whether Jesus pays, Peter says yes. Jesus then asks whom earthly kings tax: their own sons, or other people? Peter answers that they tax others, and Jesus concludes that the sons are free.
Earlier in the chapter, the voice at the Transfiguration calls Jesus the beloved Son. The conversation about the temple tax brings that identity into an everyday demand for payment. Yet Jesus chooses not to cause offense: he sends Peter to catch a fish containing a coin sufficient for both of them. His freedom does not prevent him from making provision for the payment.
Matthew ends with Jesus’ instruction. Masaccio makes the promised actions visible as well: Peter obeys at the water and then pays at the right. The miracle is therefore part of a decision about how to use freedom, rather than simply an ingenious solution to a shortage of money.
Masaccio lets us follow Jesus’ decision from instruction to payment: the Son’s freedom is expressed through a willing provision for himself and Peter.
Sources
Brancacci Chapel, Santa Maria del Carmine, Florence.
Matthew 17 — Berean Standard Bible. Matthew 17:24–27 on the sons’ exemption and the decision not to cause offense; the beloved Son in verse 5.
Also from Matthew:Marriage of the VirginThe Dream of Saint Joseph
Continue looking:The Transfiguration